January 22, 2021

Best Eye Makeup for Sensitive Eyes

Best Eye Makeup for Sensitive Skin

Wanna change up your look? We’ve reviewed the best eye makeup for sensitive eyes you can get your hands on and have it as part of your daily makeup routine.

The beauty and cosmetics industry is booming!

A lot of brands are coming up with some really cool and exciting palettes for sensitive eyes. Youtube makeup stars have views by the millions just by coming up with content about tutorials and reviews.

Eye shadow is definitely no stranger to this growing fad. And with that said, we’ve rounded up all the best eye shadows and eye shadow primers for sensitive eyes to see which one suits you best.

Best Gentle Formula
UCANBE Eyeshadow Palette
Our Pick
Lamora Eyeshadow Palette
Best Shade Options
Urban Decay Naked Palette
Table of Contents

Before We Get Started

To make the selection process easier on your part, we’ve categorized our list with regards to budget-level entries, mid-priced brackets, the best loose makeup, and the best cream eyeshadow for sensitive eyes!

Best Budget Eyeshadow Palette

Beginner makeup enthusiasts and professionals alike are fond of working with budget or drugstore eyeshadows.

Even if they don’t break the bank, they actually have excellent quality and last a long time. Here are our best picks of budget eyeshadow palettes for sensitive eyes:

Lamora Exposed Eyeshadow Palette

Our Pick

Are you looking for the best makeup for your everyday look? How about for special events? The Lamora Exposed is a great one for you!

This makeup for sensitive eyes contains 16 highly pigmented color choices. It comes with matte, metallic, satin, and shimmering earthy hues to match just every skin tone and eye color.

This makeup also comes with nude shades from soft beige to chocolatey brown, for a natural smoky eyeshadow look.

It has a rich, velvety texture that allows you to blend, shade, and shadow the makeup, just like the pros.

For best results, put on some eyeshadow primer before filling your eye with makeup. With a variety of color options and blends that mix outstandingly well, the sky is the limit for all the possible eye shadow looks you can have!

One of the many concerns on beauty products for eyes is they easily wear off. The Lamora Exposed boasts reliable staying power. It is waterproof and can withstand any weather. You need not worry about partying the night away!

That’s not all. This makeup set is packaged in a portable, slim, and lightweight palette with a magnetic lid, making it suitable for people always on the go, and just in case you need some touch-ups too.

The makeup formula is made 100% vegan with the highest quality ingredients. It’s definitely a steal, especially if you have sensitive eyes.

Pros

  • Highly blendable
  • Wide color range
  • Cruelty free
  • Serious staying power
  • Value for money

Cons

  • Difficult on dry application

UCANBE Professional Eyeshadow Palette

Best Gentle Formula

No doubt, a must-have on every makeup bag, especially if you have sensitive eyes!

The UCANBE Professional eyeshadow palette comes with 18 amazing makeup shades, with a smooth and velvety texture.

It includes 8 buttery mattes, 6 pressed pearls, 3 duo-chrome toppers, and 1 daring glitter. You’ve got something for every occasion!

Some of its colors include matte peach, natural beige, pinky-purple, and rustic red. You also have bold and dramatic metallic pink, gold, and champagne.

With so many color choices, you can layer them to fit your personal style. In fact, this is one of the preferred eyeshadows for those who love attending parties and music festivals.

Its colors are rich with a soft formula that glides around your eye shape easily, yet has serious staying power. It is made cruelty free and is safe on sensitive skin and sensitive eyes. You can even use this when you wear contact lenses.

It comes in an eye-catching and easy to carry packaging, great to give as a gift for makeup enthusiasts, or to simply add to your personal collection.

Professional makeup artists and beginners alike enjoy using this makeup for sensitive eyes.

You can look like a Hollywood star without having to break a buck. With stunning eyeshadows looks, you will surely have that confidence boost at every party, even without the booze!

Pros

  • Pigment-rich
  • Vegan and cruelty free
  • Makeup for all seasons
  • Safe around sensitive skin around the eyes
  • Affordable

Cons

  • Contains parabens and talc
  • Needs to be built up

YMH BEAUTE Palette

For bold, gorgeous colors made for the runway, for theatre, or to simply make a head-turning appearance, the YMH Beaute make eyes pop with color! And even better, every set of 9 rich colors is safe for sensitive eyes!

They have 8 themed eyeshadow palettes, for eyes that captivate any audience: Aurora, Maple Forest, Mermaids, Neon Lights, Rainbow, Rockies Sunset, Sweetheart, and Tropics. This makeup palette has it all!

This makeup for sensitive eyes is made for those in the makeup industry. You can go all out on creativity with all the colors and shades available.

The eyeshadow formula for sensitive eyes is very smooth and easily blends. It is long-lasting and smudge-proof. It’s made with high-quality ingredients, vegan and cruelty-free.

Every makeup palette is packed in a square cardboard case with custom artwork, making it great to give as gifts. Why not collect them all?

Pros

  • Hypo-allergenic for sensitive eyes
  • Vegan and cruelty-free 
  • Intense and vibrant colors
  • Easy to blend
  • Doesn’t feel chalky

Cons

  • Some colors are not as pigmented

Morphe 35O Nature Glow Eyeshadow Palette

Morphe is known for its quality and easy on the pocket brushes. Did you know their makeup for sensitive eyes is just as amazing?

Professional quality at a very affordable price, the Morphe 350 Nature Glow eyeshadow palette is one of the top choices for makeup artists and YouTube beauty vloggers all over the world.

With shades that can fit every skin tone and eye color, there’s something for every occasion on anyone.

From creamy whites to red oranges, taupes, and dark browns. From everyday colors to evening colors. You can go from work mode to nightlife mode with just one kit.

These 35 bold and beautiful colors are highly pigmented and easy to wear. For the best results, we advise putting on some eyeshadow primer first though.

It has great quality that doesn’t smudge easily around the eyes.

No matter your skin’s moisture level, your makeup will look fresh all day. No one wants crease or fading colors at the height of a party, right?

Pros

  • A lot of colors and shades
  • Professional quality yet affordable
  • Smudge, fade, and crease-resistant
  • Safe for sensitive eyes

Cons

  • No mirror on the palette
  • A bit chalky

Best Mid-Priced Eyeshadow Palette

These famous brands come up with their best selling makeup palettes for sensitive eyes in themes that often provide a specific spectrum of looks.

Although they may not be as comprehensive as some palettes that have 20-40 colors in one set, these still allow you to be experimental and adventurous. Here are our top picks:

Urban Decay Naked Palette

Best Shade Options

Urban Decay launched its NAKED series back in 2010 and since then has made a lot of headlines and waves in the fashion and entertainment industry.

In fact, it’s one of the best reviewed makeup palettes for sensitive eyes among beauty bloggers and vloggers.

Urban Decay came up with basic hues of browns and pinks and added dashes of glimmer and sparkle finishes making it comfortable for anyone to play around day and night.

You can definitely turn your eyes into a work of art with the color options on this palette.

Beauty trends include making smoky eyes out of dusty pinks, rose gold shimmers, deep bronzes, and burgundy. These highly pigmented shades can surely boost your confidence both at work and more so for after-work drinks!

Urban Decay boasts a pigment infusion system where all their eye makeup is made paraben-free, sulfate-free, and phthalate-free. It’s safe enough for sensitive eyes. Another reason for you to grab this palette as soon as possible!

For the best results and an enhanced longer-lasting look, apply some of the Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer, which we reviewed in this article as well.

Spray some All Nighter Long-Lasting Makeup setting spray on your applicator before applying the eyeshadow too.

Pros

  • High versatility
  • Nice packaging
  • Comes with its own applicator
  • Safe for sensitive eyes, sensitive skin, and contact lenses
  • Long-lasting shades

Cons

  • Be careful not to buy fake branded products online

Too Faced Chocolate Bar Eyeshadow Palette

The Too Faced Chocolate Bar eyeshadow formula for sensitive eyes is made with infused antioxidant cocoa powder. The lovely smell of chocolate just brightens up everyone’s mood.

This palette comes with 16 shades to allow a limitless number of looks. They’re extremely easy to blend too.

The palette is packaged just like an actual chocolate bar with heart-shaped tins. It even looks and smells yummy enough to eat!

With a match of lovely shades and natural fragrances, this eyeshadow set definitely makes you one hell of a treat!

Pros

  • Great option of shades
  • Delicious chocolatey smell
  • Nice packaging
  • Long-wearing
  • Safe for those with sensitive eyes, sensitive skin, and contact lenses

Cons

  • Color may be too light for some

Charlotte Tilbury Instant Eye Palette in Pillow Talk

The Pillow Talk collection allows you to visit your dainty feminine side. It’s an everyday eyeshadow set that gives off a natural, pretty, and effortless look. No wonder it’s such an instant hit!

It is a palette of 4 shades you can take to every occasion. It’s a universal seller, fit for both young and old.

Also, the formula is safe enough for people with sensitive eyes and sensitive skin. 

Pros

  • Dainty and pretty shades
  • Universally flattering for every age
  • Easy to apply
  • Easy to carry around
  • Safe for sensitive eyes

Cons

  • A bit pricey for just 4 colors

Best Cream Eyeshadow

Cream eyeshadows are a thicker formula for eye makeup.

They are stored in small plastic or glass jars and are applied with a finger, sponge, or brush. They’re highly blendable and buildable. Why not give this a shot too?

Revlon ColorStay Crème Eyeshadow

The Revlon ColorStay cream eyeshadow is a drugstore eye makeup favorite. You can purchase every color in just under $10 each!

One of the reasons people opt for cream eyeshadow forms is its buildability. Yes, with 12 colors to choose from, and 4 unique finishes (metallic, matte, pearl, and satin), you’re sure to find and combine colors that suit exactly what you are going for.

These cream eye makeup options are luxurious, waterproof, and long-wearing. It comes with a built-in applicator too. That means you get top quality without breaking the buck!

Plus, you’re assured that the formula is safe for your sensitive eyes because it doesn’t contain harsh chemicals. Contact lens wearers can also enjoy this.

Pros

  • Safe for sensitive eyes
  • Every color is highly blendable and buildable
  • Fade and crease-resistant
  • Easy to apply
  • Can be used by contact lens wearers

Cons

  • Mixed reviews on grittiness and pigmentation

Clarins Ombré Iridescent Cream-to-Powder Iridescent Eyeshadow

This is a unique one on our list. The Clarins Ombre is a hybrid form of eyeshadow that feels like a cream once applied, then dries out into a powdery, silky, and brilliant finish.

It works great when putting one layer over the other. It’s really easy to apply on the eyelids as it glides quite smoothly.

This eyeshadow contains Vitamin E derivatives that keep the lids feeling comfortable all day long. It’s also very gentle on sensitive eyes and sensitive skin so contact lens wearers will surely enjoy using it.

It promises long-wearing and stay-true color too. Now that’s value for money!

Pros

  • Light on the eyelids and on sensitive eyes
  • Buildable eyeshadow looks
  • Brilliant cream to powder technology
  • Easy to apply
  • Can be used by contact lens wearers

Cons

  • Not many reviews to check out

Best Loose Eye Makeup

Loose eye makeup is pigmented powders packed in individual jars as compared to palettes that have these powders pressed on tins.

They are as rich in color as the palettes and give the same effect.

It’s only a matter of comfortability as to which eye makeup form you prefer. But more often, pro makeup artists opt this more than the everyday woman.

SHANY Cosmetics Mineral Eyeshadow

Talk about variety and versatility, the SHANY loose eyeshadow powders are a must-have for every professional and aspiring makeup artist. Contact lens wearers can also enjoy using this product.

This set comes with 40 loose pearl and glitter eye shadow powders, individually stored in sturdy jars.

It has a fine and soft texture that allows it to easily glide along your eyelids for a smooth and satin look. The formula is also safe enough for those with sensitive eyes.

With an array of colors from pinks, greens, yellows, and browns, this beautiful and sparkly pigment-rich eye makeup set gives you endless possibilities! Let your imagination go wild.

Apart from being able to come up with the most rad looks, its mineral formula also has anti-aging and antioxidant benefits. It’s great even on sensitive skin. They’re made cruelty-free too. Isn’t that amazing?

With a wide set like this, you’d spend around $60. But that’s totally a steal for 40 colors, a storage box, and two professional eyeshadow brushes.

Pros

  • A variety of colors
  • Comes with a storage box and brushes
  • Colors are richly pigmented and long-staying
  • Multi-use for face and body
  • Safe for sensitive eyes

Cons

  • Not very easy to carry around

Best Eyeshadow Primer

Primers are your eyeshadow BFFs. BFFs gotta stick together!

I mean, can you imagine putting so much effort into getting the perfect look only to have them last for a few hours?

No way! You’re better than that!

Here are our top picks for eyeshadow primers for longer-lasting eye makeup:

Urban Decay Eye Shadow Primer Potion

The Urban Decay Eye Shadow Primer Potion is undoubtedly the best on our list, especially for sensitive eyes.

It’s an award-winning light nude eyelid primer that promises to deliver a vibrant and creaseless color that lasts all day long.

It uses polymer technology to formulate this essential element that should be in every person’s makeup stash.

It makes for a great base to prevent any creasing or fading. You can go from a busy day shift to an all-nighter without having to make one too many retouches to your eyes.

It has a creamy texture that dries up and blends nicely on all skin tones, skin types, and eye shapes. It’s vegan, cruelty-free, and paraben-free for safe and unclogged pores.

And because it contains no harsh chemicals, then it’s safe to be used by those with sensitive eyes.

A little goes a long way. People love this primer for its hygienic packaging, longevity, and excellent value for money.

Pros

  • Value for money
  • Rich formula yet feels light on the lids once prepped
  • Easy to apply
  • Long-lasting
  • Formulated for those with sensitive eyes

Cons

  • Slightly expensive

CoverGirl Lid Lock Up Eye Shadow Primer

For a more affordable option, we’ve chosen the CoverGirl Lid Lock Up primer.

It’s popular among drugstore eye makeup essentials and is often the go-to for novice artists, everyday women, and those with sensitive eyes.

In just under $9, you get this high-quality primer to prep eyelids for all-day wear. This has gotta be your best bet yet!

The CoverGirl primer swears by maximizing your eye makeup and even intensifying the colors you are wearing. Its neutral tone makes it one great option for everyone, even those with sensitive eyes.

Its smooth texture makes for an easy application. It dries quickly too. Worry not; you’ll have enough time to prep for work in the morning with this one!

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Easy to apply
  • Quick to dry
  • Nice sheerness
  • Suitable for sensitive eyes and sensitive skin

Cons

  • Eyeshadow colors not as vibrant later in the day
  • A bit tacky for some users

Bare Minerals Prime Time Eyelid Primer

Having oily eyelids is one reason why eye makeup tends to fade or melt away throughout the course of your day.

You have to be wary about your choice of primers as not all are made best to address this line of concern.

Bare Minerals is one primer specially formulated for oily eyelids and sensitive eyes. This silky and lightweight option swears at extending the life of your wear and prevent any creases.

This also helps intensify the colors of your eye makeup, leaving you looking great all day and night.

What’s great about this one, apart from being oil-free, is that it is fragrance free, is dermatologist-tested and allergy-tested too.

It’s the perfect eye makeup primer for those with sensitive skin and sensitive eyes.

Pros

  • Suitable on oily and sensitive eyelids
  • Aids in long-lasting eyeshadow color
  • Easy to use
  • Fragrance free

Cons

  • Size of packaging is small
  • Might feel chalky for some

What is the Best Eye Makeup?

Best

Eye makeup is a kind of cosmetic used to emphasize the eyes to catch people’s attention.

Eye makeup, or makeup in general, along with different hairstyles, are widely used to complement the fashion industry.

Extravagant, bold, and vibrant eye makeup colors and shades are often used by models, performers, actors, and actresses.

Or by someone who just feels being extra.

For everyday looks, eye makeup has also evolved to look more natural and subtle—lighter shades for a day in the office, and darker shades for a ladies night out.

Eye makeup can be in the form of a mascara, eyeliner pencil, and powder eyeshadow. 

Mascara and eyeliner are used to define lashes and eyes. Eyeshadow is applied around the eyelids and under the eyebrows with an applicator. It can be a sponge or a brush, or just with your fingers.

Eyeshadow is more artistic. There’s a lot you can do with all the available colors. There are also many iterations of it, like powder and cream eyeshadows.

Mascara, on the other hand, is for those with sparse eyelashes. If you have sensitive eyes, you must pick out a good mascara for sensitive eyes.

With so many options for eye makeup out there, we’ve intentionally focused on eyeshadow and eyeshadow primer for sensitive eyes in this review.

Why Should You Buy Eye Makeup?

Eye makeup should have its place in anybody’s cosmetics bag.

Wearing eyeshadow is one great way for you to show your personality and character through your eyes.

It’s fun to get creative on which shades and colors you should wear on specific events too.

A lot of parents also buy eyeshadow for their teenage children. They see it as a stepping stone for being an adult and being old enough to wear makeup in general.

With so many options and lovely packaging, it makes for a well thought of gift.

Eye makeup, however, should be something you put on to enhance your eyes and overall look, and not something for you to hide behind. Embrace your beauty! 

And also, just be cautious if you have sensitive eyes and sensitive skin since some formulas can cause irritation.

Eye Makeup Buying Guide

Buying Guide

With such a vast collection staring you down, I totally understand how buying eye makeup could be intimidating, especially for those with sensitive eyes.

If you’re not yet sure of what look you are going for, what colors suit your skin, or if a formula would possibly cause irritation for sensitive eyes, here is our helpful buying guide:

Form

Eyeshadows come in many different forms. It might take a few hits and misses to know exactly which form you are comfortable with. Here are some general types of eyeshadows:

Powder

Powder eyeshadows are the most common. They are pressed into individual tins. They are popular among newbies because of its variety of colors and ease of application. They usually come as a palette ranging from 4 to 40 colors in one set!

People with sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers tend to be weary when choosing powder eyeshadow since it’s the most likely variant to get inside the eyes. Our tip for this is to find a good formula.

Mineral Powder

Mineral powder eyeshadows have a loose pigmented formula. You use a non-static brush to apply it to your eyes. Just like the pressed powder forms, they are best for any type of application at any time of the day and night.

Just like powder, mineral powder tends to be a tricky product to use for sensitive eyes. Just be sure you get a mild and clean formula before you use it on sensitive eyes.

Cream

Cream eyeshadows have a thick textured formula. If you plan to have a lot of activity at an event yet still want to look fresh, cream eyeshadow is the one for you.

A cream eyeshadow is bolder and has more solid colors compared to the powder. One drawback though is you’ll be needing a special makeup remover to wipe it off your face.

Creams are generally safer for those with sensitive eyes since they’re less likely to budge while they’re on your eyelids. People with sensitive eyes can be more complacent when using this variant of shadow.

Pencil

Pencil eyeshadows have their formula encased in a wooden stick.

It looks a lot like your eyeliners, except it has thicker tips. They’re easy to carry around, store, and apply. They’re perfect for making touch-ups.

We highly advise you to be careful when applying pencil to sensitive eyes. Don’t apply too much pressure as pressing down too hard on sensitive eyes can cause discomfort. Also, be careful to not get the pigment inside your sensitive eyes.

Liquid

Liquid eyeshadows are usually for makeup professionals. Applying one will feel like painting, where the space around your eyes is your canvas.

Its main purpose is to accent the edges of the eyelids with stronger colors. They rarely come as palettes and are not very portable.

Like creams, liquid shadows are much safer for those with sensitive eyes. This is since once it dries on the eyelid, it’s less likely to smudge. Just be sure to wait for it to dry before you go about your day.

Skin Tone and Eye Color

When deciding which colors and shades suit you, familiarize which ones complement the colors of your skin as well as your eyes.

Ideally, you’d want to shy away from colors that exactly match your eyes. Remember, the idea of eye makeup is to let them stand out.

Finish

Another thing to consider so you don’t have to buy one too many palettes is the finished look you want to achieve.

Do you prefer a silky or matte look for an everyday office look? How about a shimmering and glittering look for a girl’s night out?

Finish is also important if you have sensitive eyes. A formula that won’t smudge or melt is good if you don’t want it to irritate highly sensitive eyes.

Versatility and Variety

You’d want to achieve a lot with just one purchase. Some eyeshadows can also be used as a highlighter or contour.

Most eyeshadow palettes come with a variety of colors you can make combinations, and layers that are well-coordinated.

You’d want a mix of mattes, neutrals, metallic, shine, and glitters to fit every occasion.

Primers

Don’t forget to prime. Primers help the colors blend better on your eyelids. It also helps keep the product last longer, avoiding creasing and fading.

Applying primer to the eye area also assures you that the makeup won’t melt away quickly. This is especially important if you have sensitive eyes. 

Ease of Application

Applying eye makeup, especially on a daily, should not be a stressful endeavor.

There are a lot of tools you can use for different forms of eyeshadows. You can use your fingers, some brushes, or a sponge.

They should glide smoothly and leave no creases. It should also be easy enough to apply to sensitive eyes. This is since something that will require more pressure during application will irritate sensitive eyes.

Pigmentation

It’s best to test the depth of its colors by making a swatch before purchasing. Some colors may be too light for your preference.

Pigmentation will also depend on the type of look you want. If you want a smokey eye, then you’ll want plenty of dark pigment.

Durability

When you’re really proud of your look, I can imagine you want to keep it as long as possible.

A good eyeshadow is waterproof and can last hours, even with a lot of activity.

Talking about durability, you also want eyeshadows neatly and securely packed. Powder eyeshadows often break when carried around often.

Although there are a lot of Youtube tutorials you can find to fix that issue, it’s always best to be wary when choosing the best packaging options.

And again, better durability is good for sensitive eyes. It lessens the chances of the makeup melting into sensitive eyes and causing irrititation.

Conclusion

Conclusion

There are one too many great options for eye makeup out there, especially for sensitive eyes. The cosmetics industry is growing by the day, coming up with the best technologies and color options to satisfy as many customers as possible.

Overall, the type of makeup you should get will depend on your skin type. If you have a sensitive skin type and sensitive eyes, then you’ll want options without harsh chemicals.

We understand making that purchase decision could be intimidating. That’s why to shorten your time, we recommend our top pick to be the Lamora Exposed Eyeshadow Palette. It’s not only good for those sensitive eyes, but for everyone else as well.

And we do hope our review on the best eye makeup for sensitive eyes has been of great help. For sure, all the makeup products we’ve reviewed here will give you a lovely experience. You may want to check out our article on the Best Eyelash Extensions for more eye options for sensitive eyes.

Do note you have the option to try more than one product, whether they made it on our list or not, by testing them out and making swatches.

All we want is for you to get the most out of your money, and turn your makeup experience into a fun and stress-free endeavor.

If you have anything to share or questions for us, feel free to leave a message in the comments section below.

For more sensitive skin and sensitive eyes options, check out these articles:

Paola Diaz
Paola Diaz

Hi, I'm Paola! A skin care enthusiast and nature lover. Creating content that promotes proper skin treatment and keeping a healthy glow is my way of sharing with the world how healthy skin can go a long way. I’m a firm believer of natural beauty that radiates inside all of us. All we need is the right kind of nourishment that inspires our wellness from inside out. So it’s really not about physical beauty alone – it’s the beautiful life we can create for ourselves when we connect with our own nature and see there is beauty that shines from every one of us.